NBA Live 15’s transition could win back fans: Hands-on preview

by Gaetano 'Xbot' Prestia 12 Comments 31 Likes 8,770 Views 14/08/2014 Back to PS4 articles NBA Live 15

It’s been a long road back for a franchise crippled by a lack of innovation. Throughout the ‘00s, NBA Live’s annual releases stagnated as it struggled in the transition to the Xbox 360 and PS3. This lead to its eventual demise in 2010 as 2K Sports’ NBA 2K series blitzed ahead quicker than a Clippers fast break.

It was heartbreaking for me, someone that had grown up playing the NBA Live series since its beginnings in 1994, right as Jordan mania spread across the globe. Ironically, just as the series had lampooned itself to the top on the back of Jordan’s Bulls, the series’ 2010 collapse was just as rapid and crushing as the Bulls’ fall from grace after Jordan’s retirement.

Five years since NBA Live 10, and after disastrous launch attempts with NBA Elite 11 and NBA Live 13, not to mention last year’s frustratingly poor reboot, NBA Live 15 has a lot of ground to make up. Thankfully, this year’s game is more than just a step in the right direction: it’s a late-season push for that final playoff spot.

PRE-SEASON PERIL


The very first thing I notice is the game’s dramatically improved visuals. Character models, animations and collision mechanics seem fitting for a game on two very powerful consoles. The players don’t have that shiny, waxy appearance they did last year, and there’s an attention to detail that we just haven’t seen in an NBA Live game before.

Portland’s DeShaun Wiggins sets the scene early in an informative tutorial that guides players through the game’s fundamentals. Shooting has been given a major tweaking, guided by an improved shooting ring on the floor around the player that uses green and red rhythm indicators. Releasing within the right window and you’ll nail the jumper. It’s very much like NBA 2K’s system, telling you if you've released too early or too late. It certainly feels better that last year’s game, and seeing how the game runs in a match situation gave me high hopes for a refined basketball experience that understands the complexities of the sport.

It’s no secret that last year’s game simply lacked the visual fidelity to enhance that sense of realism we expect from a sports sim. This year we get a complete rework. The likes of Durant and LeBron jump, dribble and drive with an uncanny similarity to their real-life counterparts. That just didn’t exist in last year’s game. This virtual interpretation of The King is intimidating and demanding on the court, standing out like the big-chested, powerful player he is. Again, NBA Live 14 just didn’t amplify this sense of belonging on the court, and that made the experience difficult to embrace. With NBA Live 15, players seem more like scans of the actual players, as opposed to the weird, lanky designs of last year’s effort.

CLUTCH


The core gameplay feels significantly better. Passing, dribbling, skill moves, and, most importantly, shooting, all embrace this reworked animations system that makes for a more satisfying and rewarding basketball experience. No longer is Durant’s jumper lacking that recognisable style that defines his game. LeBron’s iconic one-step fadeaway jumper seems like something he would actually do. It’s astonishing how far the game has come, and even more astonishing that is was so far behind this in the first place.

It’s not perfect: this still very much feels like a game that’s being experimented on. Sometimes it works really well, and then other times it goes back into its shell, reliving the disastrous, outdated stylings of NBA Live from previous years. Sometimes it feels like NBA Live 15 wants to lose, but then it surprises you and feels like the basketball game that fans of the series have been waiting a long, long time for.

Perspective is important here, because the EA Sports team needs to create a game that understands the punishing fundamentals of a match of basketball. It always needed to feel less like a game and more like a sim, but the challenge is still ensuring the game is fun even in the face of that complexity. NBA 2K has iconically established itself as one of the premiere sports franchises precisely because it manages to blend accessibility with rigorous complexity.

That complexity exists in NBA Live 15, it’s just that sometimes it lacks the tightness to make it a great basketball game: it almost always just felt like a good game, never great. Of course, I’m seeing a pre-release demo, and it’s clear that there are significant strides still to be made. But early signs are promising, and I have no uncertainty that NBA Live 15 is an infinitely better basketball project than NBA Live 14, not that it would be hard to top that game.

BODY ART


There’s still work here to be done. Bench, coach and crowd models are better, but they’re a few levels below what’s happening on the court. What I did see of the players was a major improvement on character models over last year's game, and certainly models that take it right up to NBA 2K14. Of course, at time of print I am yet to have seen 2K15, but the promising thing is that at least NBA Live 15 has made major inroads. NBA Live 14 looked like a game from four or five years before 2K14, but now it might only be a year or so. Again, it’s difficult to compare to this year’s game, but NBA 2K14 still set a high enough benchmark to make a feasible comparison.

The ESPN coverage branding is back again, and while I didn’t see enough of it outside of the game I played (full match, five-minute quarters), the commentary banter is less mechanical than it was in NBA Live 14. It’s a little silly, but certainly more involved with what’s happening on the court. Seeing NBA Live 15 in action makes me wonder how and why NBA Live 14 was even released, because almost all of the major facets put last year’s game to shame.

What I really liked about how the game played and looked was just that feel of power, collision and strength. That didn’t exist previously. LeBron feels powerful. It’s hard to put a finger on it, because I haven’t had to actually explain such a major improvement year-on-year in a basketball game before, but to put it simply, NBA Live 15 feels like the basketball game EA Sports has been trying to make since NBA Elite 11. It just feels like a better product, one that blends complex fundamentals with satisfying spin moves and punishing turnovers. Again, it’s not perfect -- off-ball AI could do with some tweaking, but for the most part, player moving and cutting have an enhanced sense of awareness -- but it’s a promisingly improved sense of responsiveness that makes it a more enjoyable and challenging basketball experience.

THE RUN HOME


I can’t promise that NBA Live 15 will be a great game, but I can promise that it’ll be better than NBA Live 14. And not just a few tweaks here and there: this is a completely new basketball package. The basketball fundamentals have been given a complex do-over, and for the most part, it plays like a basketball game should.

Finally, after a long five years, it seems EA Sports is back on the road to redemption. The question is: are you willing to go back? At this stage, my ticket’s booked and my bag’s packed: I'm ready for a road trip!

Vote for this article Log in with Facebook

NBA Live 15’s transition could win back fans: Hands-on preview Comments

  • 1wiierdguy 8564 XP 14/08/2014
    Improved or just good is not enough for a switch. This would have to be better than 2k for that.
  • zurczner 8426 XP 15/08/2014
    They said they wouldn't integrate cut scenes in the game so i reckon it to not have something like Rising Stars from 2K, which is a bummer. Still want to look more into this though
  • Leave your comment Log in with Facebook
  • Gryllis 344432 XP 15/08/2014
    Strange that it's now given to press to preview, but there are no new assets.

    Either they just didn't have them ready in time for Gamescom (weird), or....
  • stonecold 33253 XP 15/08/2014
    It will fail again up against 2K.
    2K should do an AFL game
  • punk 12533 XP 16/08/2014
    I don't shed a tear at all with EA being on the back end of 2K.

    EA is all about the micro-transactions these days.

    I'd be up for a 2k AFL game.
  • barters81 5574 XP 17/08/2014

    @punk said: I don't shed a tear at all with EA being on the back end of 2K.
    EA is all about the micro-transactions these days.
    I'd be up for a 2k AFL game.



    2K's VC system in 2K14 is the reason I'd be interested in an alternative.
  • espi_band 201 XP 18/08/2014
    2K14 already has an established fanbase, and going up to par with it won't help them win people. They should be better than 2K14 as a whole to win back Live fans again.
  • soofany05 250 XP 18/08/2014
    There is too much bashing on Live 15 on these newer ones.

    I miss the times when Live was superior than 2K
  • Tano 340518 XP 18/08/2014

    @barters81 said:

    @punk said: I don't shed a tear at all with EA being on the back end of 2K.
    EA is all about the micro-transactions these days.
    I'd be up for a 2k AFL game.


    2K's VC system in 2K14 is the reason I'd be interested in an alternative.



    It was very broken and actually got worse with updates.
  • Stu 7005 5892 XP 18/08/2014
    I thought NBA 2k15 was on show at games com? I saw a video but it looked fairly similar to 14.
  • Latif145 2 XP 18/08/2014
    The you see with gamers mainly sports gamers is the choosing of sides LIVE15 is a game I'm buying as well as 2K's.I'm not Loyal to a video Game
  • Tano 340518 XP 27/08/2014

    @Hugo said: I thought NBA 2k15 was on show at games com? I saw a video but it looked fairly similar to 14.



    It was.
Leave your comment Log in with Facebook